This is about a common talk in Industrial Environment that these days Industry Ready Engineers are not available.I accept this fact, but I try to view this from a different angle also and want to share the same to a larger cross section of Industry on PAN India basis.
There are certain myths about Industry and Engineers.
Let us understand the different points which I term as myths one by one and put efforts to remove these myth and attack on many other issues.
1 Colleges are not producing Industry Ready Engineers.
Here, please ask yourself, did any Medical college produce any patient ready doctor even after internship during college studies; did any Education Professional college produce a Student Ready Teacher; Did any Law college produce a court ready advocate.
Answer to all these is Big No!
In all the above professions, the new graduate is put in to practice through training and tried and treated rigorously by their seniors.
Similarly a new engineer has to be trained , tried and treated.
2 Engineers don't work only Mistry/technicians really work.
If an Engineer doesn't work, he is not a Engineer, he is a munshi or admin. supervisor.
But a trained and treated engineer available on the Shop floor, he can not avoid working. He will have to come on the scene ready to work with work force.In such case Mistry loves to work in his supervision , guidance and leadership.A trained engineer works to lead the team at different works or jobs.He does the precision works.
3 a Mistry or Technicians are more capable of working.
Apparently this is so. A Mistry is a Mistry and Engineer is an Engineer. While a Mistry knows only how, the Engineer is supposed to know why and how both!
Mistry are skilled in doing the task, but without regards to costs, quality and delivery commitment.
4 a Employing Engineers is a costly affair.
Again this is apparent only at first instance, The so called Jugads by experienced Mistry or Technician prove to be more costly in long run, spoils the branding and hence dents the Competitiveness and sustainability of the industry.Jugads have to be done as stop gap arrangements. I have experienced personally a number of times in my career. (सौ सुनार की एक लोहार की) 100 blows of a gold smith are equal to 1 blow of black smith.
I consider some time Jugad is unavoidable but is a step out of Box and can not be made a regular practice.
Employing a trained and Industry Ready Engineer is always economical and useful in branding and making the Industry sustainable.
5. Training Cost on Engineers go unproductive.
Yes, if engineer does not stay with the Industry for 2/3/4 years. Because Industry takes risk of training new Engineer. If he escapes the industry prematurely, industry gets upset.
Solution to all the above issues are:
College should focus on Academic enrichment of their students,
Students should be motivated to take Vocational Trades Training with Employability orientation from 3rd agency.
This will enhance Employability of fresh graduate engineers,
This will increase no of Qualified Engineers in industry in turn productivity of Industry.
This will dilute the risk from recruitment of raw Engineers.
Overall this will strengthen the sustainability of Industries.
Writer is an experienced engineering management professional and a mentor and trainer to engineers.